Do LDS patriots shun protest?
Scholar sees reluctance to oppose policy in Iraq
Brian Birch, an associate professor of philosophy and director of the religious studies program at Utah Valley State College, said members of the LDS Church often do not "renounce war and proclaim peace" — even though church scriptures instruct them to do so — because of a deeply imbedded patriotism.
Latter-day Saints believe the United States was divinely instituted as a covenant land between God and members of his church, and that keeps some church members from challenging the government, Birch said.
"The danger for Mormons with ideas like this lies in confusing theology with nationalistic rhetoric and confusing civil protests with unpatriotic activity," he said.
Birch was one of four religious academics who participated in a dialogue about religious perspectives during "An Interfaith Conference on War and Peace" at the Salt Lake City Library auditorium.
The event featured discussions about Jewish, Christian, Islamic and LDS Church perspectives on war in general, as well as specifically on the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.
"Acknowledging the commonalities (between the religious perspectives and traditions) allows us to work together in achieving peace. I also think it's important to recognize the differences."
The LDS Church has taken no official position on the war in Iraq, Birch said, leaving its members to make up their own minds regarding the justification of the war. The invasion and occupation of Iraq has been renounced by nearly all major Christian denominations, he said, with the exception of the LDS Church and the Southern Baptist Convention.
That leaves people to speculate as to the reasons for the LDS Church's silence. The practice of church leadership has been to not make a statement on a particular topic unless there is unanimity among the church's First Presidency and the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, Birch said.
"One speculation is that they can't get consensus among themselves to make an official statement about the war," he said.
Comments from church leaders further complicate the situation, Birch said.
In his April 2003 General Conference remarks, LDS Church President Gordon B. Hinckley spoke of his personal support for the war but made it clear that it was his position and not an official statement of the church.
Recent comments
I am a soldier in the United States Military. I am formerly a member...
american? | June 21, 2008 at 9:22 a.m.
Isa. 51: 20
20 Thy sons have fainted, they lie at the head...
Bob Mullins - Logan Utah | Feb. 16, 2008 at 6:18 p.m.
The first peace, which is the most important, is that which comes...
Black Elk | Oct. 14, 2007 at 5:03 p.m.
