Avoid harmful tax fixes

Of the many property-tax reforms that seem to be flooding the state Capitol these days, only a few deserve much consideration. The truth is, very little about Utah's current property-tax system needs fixing.

One idea under consideration would require counties to reassess all properties within the county each year. Frankly, if this had been in place years ago, the problems encountered statewide this year, as property values rose much faster than normal, would have been avoided.

Salt Lake County already reassesses all properties each year. This year, 7,537 property owners contested their assessments in formal appeals. That represents a meager 2.28 percent of the total parcels countywide and was a slight increase over the 1.67 percent who appealed in 2006. Neither level is indicative of a major problem that needs correcting.

Another reasonable idea under consideration would extend discounts to the elderly. But this should be available only to those of meager means. Current law already provides relief in those cases. In fact, nobody seems capable of pointing to a single instance in Utah of a low-income homeowner losing a house to the tax collector.

The list of harmful bills under consideration is too long to mention in detail. The worst of these would require a public vote every time local governments wish to raise taxes beyond the certified rate. Given that so few people bother to respond to public notices today as to when public hearings will be held for the purpose of considering a tax increase, what evidence is there that requiring a public vote would increase public involvement or lead to better government? If anything, such a requirement would bog down local governments and keep them from enacting the occasional legitimate tax increase.

Another proposal would assess properties on a rolling five-year average, rather than on their estimated value each year. This supposedly would prevent the spikes experienced this year. In fact, those spikes are best handled by requiring yearly assessments, as Salt Lake County currently provides.

The problem isn't so much that property values fluctuate year to year. State law already requires that tax rates be adjusted up or down to ensure a local government does not collect more money one year than another. The problem is that some counties assess homes only once in several years.

The state's truth-in-taxation law has managed to keep a rein on taxes through the years. Our advice to lawmakers is to require yearly assessments, then put all the other ideas on hold for a year. Given current real estate conditions, chances are the need for quick fixes will disappear by then.

Recent comments

• Most Popular
• Most Commented

1. Jewish family makes peace with LDS baptism
2. Lindon family's sinking-home nightmare brings $3.1 million award
3. BYU football: For Cougars, MWC is priority number one
4. Lobos will bring the heat in frosty Provo
5. Shame on LDS Church
6. MormonTimes.com: Original 'Poor Wayfaring Man' had different tune
7. Utah Jazz: Backup point guard contenders both look good
8. Palin unlawfully abused power in trooper firing, inquiry finds
9. College football gameday
10. Utah Jazz: Sloan still has high opinion of Collins

1. Shame on LDS Church 422
2. LDS Church urges pro-Proposition 8 calls 282
3. Calls about Prop. 8 not imminent 214
4. High school football: Top 25 190
5. Sparks fly over lousy economy 165
6. Speed gamer: BYU's Collie average on the track, unbeatable on the field 145
7. Hats off to Sakoda, Rams, Aggies, Cougs 118
8. Details on new LDS temples revealed 103
9. Grand opening, but ... Real Salt Lake fails to make up ground in MLS playoff push 99
10. Palin is breath of fresh air 96
11. (Stories published in the last five days with the most comments)

• Utah
• Sports
• Business