How much coal?

A conversation last summer between two Utah legislators shows the lack of consensus about how much coal Utah still has.

Rep. Mike Noel, co-chairman of the Utah Legislature's Public Utilities and Technology Interim Committee, was sparring with committee member Rep. Lynn N. Hemingway over legislation that could be modeled on a Florida law allowing utilities to recoup the cost of nuclear power plant construction.

Hemingway, D-Holladay, said as far as he was concerned, Utah and Florida are like apples and oranges. Other than nuclear power, Florida has no way to generate electrical power — "absolutely none."

On the other hand, he added, "I would just warn that we have a lot of alternatives that I hope would come before nuclear."

"Just maybe clarify," Noel queried. "What are those alternatives, Representative?"

Hemingway: "Our coal reserves, number one."

Noel replied, "And I guess I maybe would question that because of the testimony I've heard in this committee for the last several years, that our coal reserves are on a steep decline, and that the coal that we're now extracting is at over a thousand feet (depth) and it's very marginal, it's very expensive, and now we're getting the pressures from the carbon impact of that coal."

Three months after the discussion took place, news broke that the Kane County Water Conservancy District, whose executive director is Noel, had signed a potentially lucrative agreement to supply water to a planned privately funded nuclear power plant.

Recent comments

• Most Popular
• Most Commented

1. BYU football: Quest still alive — Cougars remain perfect, but it isn't easy
2. BYU football: Cougar win seems just like old times
3. Death on the line
4. Jewish family makes peace with LDS baptism
5. All that money you've lost — where did it go? Did it exist?
6. College football polls: BYU 8, 9; Utah 13, 14
7. Utah Jazz: Players ready for 'real' season
8. BYU football: Long bemoans call that 'changed momentum'
9. BYU football: Mendenhall not surprised by fourth-and-one decision
10. Utah Utes football: Special teams, defense lead Utes to 7-0 record

1. Shame on LDS Church 470
2. LDS Church urges pro-Proposition 8 calls 291
3. Calls about Prop. 8 not imminent 217
4. Sparks fly over lousy economy 168
5. BYU football: Quest still alive — Cougars remain perfect, but it isn't easy 165
6. Speed gamer: BYU's Collie average on the track, unbeatable on the field 146
7. Utah Utes football: Special teams, defense lead Utes to 7-0 record 117
8. Palin unlawfully abused power in trooper firing, inquiry finds 105
9. Details on new LDS temples revealed 103
10. Grand opening, but ... Real Salt Lake fails to make up ground in MLS playoff push 99
11. (Stories published in the last five days with the most comments)

• A & E
• LDS news
• Sports