Dental funding sidestepped

GOP lawmakers vote to keep issue in committee

Published: Thursday, May 25, 2006 3:07 p.m. MDT
E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
Without taking an up-or-down vote, Republicans in the Utah Legislature sidestepped the main, controversial issue before a special session Wednesday: $2 million to pay for dental work for blind and disabled Utahns.

Providing the extra Medicaid funds "is the right and moral thing to do," Rep. David Litvack, D-Salt Lake, pleaded with the House Rules Committee after Senate Republicans had already refused to hear the issue.

But on party line votes — Republicans opposing the spending, Democrats for it — the $2 million bill was held by the committee. It was also withheld from the Senate floor in a party line vote of the full Senate.

While lawmakers refused to authorize $2 million for poor people's dental care, they approved spending $15 million to build a 270-car parking garage east of the now-under-renovation state Capitol Building.

"We are disappointed that (the $2 million for disabled Utahns' dental care) did not even come up for a debate," said Mike Mower, Gov. Jon Huntsman Jr.'s deputy chief of staff and spokesman.

"We recognize that ultimately (the $2 million for Medicaid dental) is a decision for the Legislature," said Mower.

Story continues below
"We thought we had a compromise last night — the $2 million was found within the current Health Department budget. We found the money, that's what was important. We will visit this issue again," if not in another special session then in the general session next January, Mower promised.

Republicans' decision not to debate the bill at all was made with expediency in mind, said Senate President John Valentine, R-Orem.

"There's no need to debate a bill that's going to fail," he said.

The action enraged and saddened the several dozen Medicaid recipients who gathered at the Capitol Wednesday afternoon to urge lawmakers to vote in favor of the funding.

"This is an asinine perspective for them to take with people who have need," said Salt Lake resident Hal Jackson. "The leaders of this community need to consider whether they represent the people, who are the heart of the community."

"This is about politics, it's not about people," said a tearful Ricki Landers, who earlier in the day had joined a group that gathered outside the House Chambers holding out their caps and begging for money for dental and vision benefits for adult Medicaid beneficiaries.

"I don't think they could send any more clear of a message," said Bill Tibbitts with Crossroads Urban Center. "What they're saying is 65,000 Medicaid recipients don't matter. That's what they're saying."

The $2 million would have attracted nearly $5 million in matching federal dollars and would have allowed an estimated 40,000 blind, aged and disabled Utahns to receive emergency dental care. A full restoration of dental benefits, a so-called "optional" service under the Medicaid program, would cost $3.9 million and served 65,000 recipients.

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.

Medicaid recipients demonstrate in hopes $2 million in funding for dental care would be approved. (Tom Smart, Deseret Morning News)
Tom Smart, Deseret Morning News
Medicaid recipients demonstrate in hopes $2 million in funding for dental care would be approved.