Forestry group blasted for 'green-washing'

Published: Thursday, Sept. 27, 2007 12:24 a.m. MDT
E-MAIL | PRINT | FONT + - 
An organization that certifies companies for environmentally friendly logging operations is holding its annual convention in Utah and has brought with it some controversies surrounding corporate "green-washing" and labor disputes.

The Sustainable Forestry Initiative, which is meeting at Snowbird until the end of this week, is establishing standards to encourage timber companies to manage the resources in a way that goes "beyond regulatory requirement," SFI President Kathey Abusow said. The certifications, which are awarded to the forest lands owned by the companies, allow companies to market their products as "green" materials.

The SFI certification has drawn criticism from some environmental groups, especially the Sierra Club, which characterized the certification as industry "green-washing."

Abusow disagreed, pointing out that the organization is independent and nonprofit, that groups such as the Pacific Forest Trust and the Nature Conservancy have served on the SFI board of directors and that the certification process is rigorous.

But according to the Sierra Club, the only acceptable standard is granted by the Forest Stewardship Council. That organization, which the Sierra Club spearheaded, sets its standards to insure responsible forest management by considering everything from ecosystem protection to rights of workers and indigenous peoples.

Story continues below
The Utah conference this week also drew questions about the labor practices of one SFI member. On Wednesday, the United Steelworkers held simultaneous news conferences in Salt Lake and Vancouver, British Columbia, regarding TimberWest, a company based in British Columbia. The union contends that the company is flaunting environmental regulations and ruining watersheds throughout the coastal forests.

The union representatives want SFI to better enforce its standards. "We don't want them to just be a rubber stamp organization," said William Routley, president of Steelworkers Local 1-80 in Duncan, British Columbia.

TimberWest said in a statement that the charges leveled by the union are inaccurate. The company also said claimed that the union is only raising the issue now because of a labor dispute in western Canada.

Abusow said that while TimberWest is SFI certified, the union can appeal to a third-party auditor for a review of that certification.


E-mail: jloftin@desnews.com

Comments

You can be the first to comment on this story.