Reader comments: Happiness
AVI GREEN | Jan. 5, 2000
In the past several weeks, I've been wondering if I did the
right thing to be favorable towards "American Beauty".
Could I have made a mistake? I dunno. Whatever, I'm most
certainly not fooled by this abomination. Whether or not
American Beauty glorifies pedophilia, this movie seems to
justify it. It seems to sympathise with sex offenders, and
promote such distasteful subjects as comedy too. And I'm
furious. I'd like to put a good stinging welt across Todd
Solondz's creepy face for daring to make yet another movie
for the purpose of corrupting people's minds and for making
yet another movie for the purpose of dumbing down the
public's intelligence level too. Oh yeah, he most certainly
should go to jail for making such filth. Mr. Solondz, shame
on you and all your decendants until the end of time! Get
out of town!
JARROD HESSE | May. 4, 1999
Hey Jeff Vice: You say that Happiness suffers from
technical dificiencies, but you don't explain what they
are. Do you know why? Because there isn't any, and even
though you actually liked the way the movie was made, you
were personally offended by it, and you had to find
something, ANYTHING, bad to say about it. My advice to
you: Try to remain professional, please. My advice to
everyone else: Watch Happiness. It is incredible.
SARAH | Mar. 30, 1999
Anyone who so casually dismisses Happiness as an
unwatchable film due to subject matter has been
unfortunately blinded in the search to abide by America's
puritanical value system. I suggest that what makes
Happiness so disturbing is not simply that it "dares to
treat the subjects of obscene phone-callers and pedophilia
in a surprisingly straightforward manner." but rather that
it makes you the viewer *identify* with this characters.
To make the "normal" understand and empathize with the
"abnormal" is an amazing artistic feat, one worthy of
Cannes film festival's Grand Prize.
Perhaps Happiness is not a film meant for everyone, but I
would suggest that the fault lies not in the film itself
but in the viewers insecurity with his own psyche. If the
film were not disturbing, then it would not be effective.
The message is dark and cynical, specifically, that
Happiness is not achievable and those who think it is are
deluding themselves.
Besides the amazing message and ability to communicate that
message, Happiness is a wonderfully written screenplay. It
rejects Hollywood conventional writing, by lacking a true
protagonist and a true antagonist. We feel sympathy for
all the characters and yet we are distant from all the
characters. There is unity in the relationships of the
characters to each other but there is no true unity of
plot, ie there is no one storyline to which every scene
attempts to progress. Yet, despite all this, we are still
engaged and we are satisfied with the ending (although we
may not like it- we feel resolution). The screenplay in
itself is pure genius.
Second, there is not one weak actor portraying any of
Happiness's major characters. This is very
uncharacteristic in a film with so many diverse and full
parts.
I would agree however, that Happiness's major flaw is the
rather bland cinematography. However, many major
blockbuster's cinematography is more bland masking itself
in the excitement of mise-en-scene (aka Armageddon).
Add your comment
Words Remaining
New Movie Trailers
Top Box Office
| 1. | Four Christmases | $31,069,826.00 |
| 2. | Bolt | $26,581,002.00 |
| 3. | Twilight | $26,344,032.00 |
| 4. | Quantum of Solace | $18,833,552.00 |
| 5. | Australia | $14,800,723.00 |
| 6. | Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa | $14,207,329.00 |
| 7. | Transporter 3 | $12,063,452.00 |
| 8. | Role Models | $5,191,180.00 |
| 9. | The Boy in the Striped Pajamas | $1,696,187.00 |
| 10. | Milk | $1,453,844.00 |


