Jeff, your not the best movie critic, but seriously, could you not like this film, maybe if you freak out about every little detail but that makes all movies dumb if you focus on there bad points. So do you think that sean penns perormence did not help this movie, and he made this movie great. This is defintly a watch, and most of Jeff's ratings suck.

I have found that jeffs reviews are usually right on the money. It was a really stupid movie. a sappy movie for sappy people!

This movie was extremely touching and heartfelt. I agree with a previous inquiry that questioned our critics judgement. I cant bring myself to read his opinions because he ALWAYS hates the movies I like.....and appears to be extremely bias. I would faint if he ever gave credit where it was due....or credit to anyone at all. "I am sam" should receive many awards for both the incredible performances, and the content of this very intelligent movie! And every other critic I have heard has praised the film. GO SEE IT! (But take kleenex!)

This is one of the best movies in a while. Sean Penn should get an Oscar nomination for his work. Mr. Vice appears to dislike almost every movie he reviews. I can't figure out why he is a movie critic if he doesn't like movies. I never use his review as a basis if I will see a movie or not because I would never get to see any.

This movie should win the academy Their will be some who hate it and some who love it. I love this movie. Before you change your mind because of a bad review. Watch it and find out for yourself.

Mr. Vice tries so hard to remain detached, he should go to work at child protective services. His cynicism wears thin.