Reader comments: The Seeker: The Dark Is Rising
ARWEN | Oct. 16, 2007
The movie got it all wrong!!!! Wrong! Wrong! Wrong! It
ruined a wonderful story. (spoilers from the book ahead)
Will Stanton did not have a twin brother, though two of his
older brothers are twins, Paul and James. Paul plays the
flute and James loves to sing. Neither of them got kidnapped
by the way. Will is the youngest of a very close and tight
knit family. Will always felt loved, supported, and
protected. He is also a responsible, well mannered, and
thoughtful child. No dysfunction there! Imagine that!!!
The oldest, Tom who died in infancy, is mentioned in the
book but does not play a roll in the story. The second to
the oldest, Steven, whom Will loved and looked up to, is in
the British Royal Navy. Steven gave Will his attic bedroom
because Will absolutely loved it. Will was 11 years old
when the story took place and had no interest in girls at
the time. He found his abilities, at times, a burden. Unlike
in the movie, Will takes Merriman?s advice and teachings
very seriously. He is British, NOT an American. The movie
does not resemble the book at all, not even close!! Did the
producers and directors even read the book!! I think not.
They forgot a very important rule, Never Americanize British
Novels!! Those who have not read the books are in for a
surprise when they do. "Is this the same story?" they will
ask. Those who have read the books will be sorely
disappointed and will ask the same question. I don't mind
movie adaptations of books. Quite of few are very well done
such as "Lord of the Rings?, The Lion, the Witch and the
Wardrobe" and they even did a fair job with "Harry Potter.?
The entire Celtic Mythology and Arthurian Legend have been
removed in the movie. The producers and Directors really
butchered the "Dark is Rising." There are 5 books in the
complete story of the "Dark is Rising." The 1st one is
called, "Over the Sea, Under the Stone", the 2nd, "The Dark
is Rising," The 3rd, 'the Green Witch", The 4th, "The Grey
King"-- Newberry award winner, and the last book is called
"Silver on the Tree." Very excellent books and a wonderful
read. Skip the movie. Read the books!!
C DYE | Oct. 4, 2007
Based *loosely* on the award winning books by Susan
Cooper. And judging from the reviews, very loosely
indeed. You'd be better off going to the library.
Add your comment
Words Remaining
New Movie Trailers
Top Box Office
| 1. | Four Christmases | $31,069,826.00 |
| 2. | Bolt | $26,581,002.00 |
| 3. | Twilight | $26,344,032.00 |
| 4. | Quantum of Solace | $18,833,552.00 |
| 5. | Australia | $14,800,723.00 |
| 6. | Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa | $14,207,329.00 |
| 7. | Transporter 3 | $12,063,452.00 |
| 8. | Role Models | $5,191,180.00 |
| 9. | The Boy in the Striped Pajamas | $1,696,187.00 |
| 10. | Milk | $1,453,844.00 |


